Many With Metastatic Kidney Cancer Can Forego Surgery

Article

For many patients diagnosed with metastatic renal cell carcinoma, sunitinib alone is not inferior to surgery followed by sunitinib.

For many patients with newly diagnosed metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC), it is possible to forego surgery without reducing survival time, according to results from the randomized phase III noninferiority CARMENA study (abstract LBA3), presented at the 2018 American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) Annual Meeting, held June 1–5 in Chicago.

Median overall survival among patients receiving only sunitinib was 18.4 months compared with 13.9 months for surgery and sunitinib therapy, the current standard of care, reported study coauthor Arnaud Mejean, MD, PhD, of the Hôpital Européen Georges-Pompidou, Paris Descartes University in France.

This finding should allow some patients to avoid the risk of surgical complications like infection and pulmonary embolism, noted Sumanta K. Pal, MD, of City of Hope Comprehensive Cancer Center in Duarte, California.

Kidney removal and recovery from surgery also delay tumor-directed therapy for a period of several weeks, sometimes allowing tumors the opportunity to progress.

“Until now, nephrectomy has been considered the standard of care for patients with kidney cancer who have metastatic disease when the cancer is first diagnosed,” Mejean said. “Our study is the first to question the need for surgery in the era of targeted therapies, and clearly shows that surgery for certain people with kidney cancer should no longer be the standard of care.”

The study enrolled 450 patients diagnosed with mRCC and randomly assigned them to receive either surgery followed 4 to 6 weeks later by sunitinib targeted therapy or sunitinib without surgery. Importantly, patients with only one metastasis, or who for other reasons did not require systemic therapy, were not enrolled. For these patients, nephrectomy remains the “gold standard,” Mejean noted.

At a follow-up of 50.9 months, survival was comparable between the two study groups overall (18.4 months without surgery compared with 13.9 months with surgery), as well as in subgroup analyses for poor- and intermediate-risk patients.

Tumor response rates were also similar between the two groups (27% vs 29%), and median time to progression was 8.3 months compared with 7.2 months for patients undergoing surgery.

Because the study was designed to determine noninferiority rather than superiority, it cannot be concluded that sunitinib alone outperforms surgery followed by sunitinib.

Recent Videos
A phase 0 trial is seeking to assess the feasibility of aiding anti-cancer cells with cytokines to restore their function.
Although pembrolizumab addressed a long-standing need in adjuvant kidney cancer treatment, combinations with the agent may further bolster efficacy.
“The trial will be successful, or [we’ll] declare it a success if we see at least 3 of 24 responses overall,” stated Ravi, MD, BChir, MRCP, on the phase 2 LASER trial in RCC.
Success with the 177Lu-PSMA-617 radioligand therapy would be transformative for the clear cell renal cell carcinoma treatment landscape.
An ongoing phase 1 trial seeks to prove XmAb819 as an effective treatment and ENPP3 as a plausible target in patients with relapsed or refractory RCC.
“The therapy is designed to prevent both CAR T-cell inactivation and to restore the anti-tumor immunity of the white blood cells that have gotten through the tumor,” said Marasco, MD, PhD.
Ongoing studies aim to combine base immunotherapy regimens with novel agents to potentially improve outcomes among patients with kidney cancer.
Investigators have found a way to reduce liver and biliary toxicity when targeting the molecule CAIX in patients with clear cell renal cell carcinoma.
Neoantigen-targeting vaccines resulted in an absence of recurrence in 9 patients with high-risk kidney cancer, according to David A. Braun, MD, PhD.
The Kidney Cancer Research Consortium may allow collaborators to form more mechanistic and scientifically driven efforts in the field.
Related Content